After working with nearly every animal you could think of, Tye Rinner settled on turkeys, now raising between 70,000 to 74,000 commercial turkeys annually for West Liberty Foods from his farm in Washington County. 

“I just like the way turkeys are,” Rinner said. “They’re not a very large animal. They’re not going to knock you over like a mama cow when you’re trying to tag a calf or take you out at the knees like a market hog.”

His diversified operation in­cludes two brooder houses,...